top of page

Home &

Auto Insurance 


Much More...

Top 10 Reasons Landlord Insurance Claims Get Denied

As a landlord, safeguarding your investment through proper insurance coverage is crucial. However, even with insurance in place, there are scenarios where claims might be denied. In this comprehensive guide, we'll examine common reasons why landlord insurance claims can be denied, focusing on the critical factor of property condition. We'll provide detailed explanations, offer preventive measures, and illustrate each point with real-life examples to help you protect your investment effectively.

Landlords discover they've been denied a claim
Landlords discover they've been denied a claim

1. Vacant or Unoccupied Unit

Explanation: If your rental property remains vacant or unoccupied for an extended period without proper notification to the insurer, your claim might be denied. Insurance policies often have clauses that limit coverage or impose specific conditions for properties that are vacant or unoccupied.

Prevention: When your rental unit becomes vacant or unoccupied, promptly inform your insurance company and inquire about vacancy coverage options. Some policies might require you to purchase additional coverage to protect against risks associated with vacant properties.

Example: Robert's rental property had been unoccupied for several months as he searched for a new tenant. During this time, a burst pipe caused extensive water damage. Unfortunately, his claim was denied because he had not notified the insurer about the property's vacancy, and the policy did not cover damage sustained during unoccupancy.

In this situation, Robert could have prevented the claim denial by notifying his insurance company about the vacant status of the unit and inquiring about vacancy coverage options. Taking these steps would have ensured that his property remained adequately protected even during periods of unoccupancy.

2. Student Housing or Shared Accommodations

Explanation: Insurers often have specific guidelines for properties used as student housing or shared accommodations. If your rental property is being used in a way that deviates from the policy's intended use, a claim might be denied.

Prevention: When purchasing landlord insurance, ensure you accurately disclose the property's use, including whether it will be used for student housing or shared accommodations. If you make changes to the property's use, notify your insurer promptly.

Example: Lisa's rental property was primarily used as a single-family dwelling, but she later converted it into shared accommodations for students. When a fire occurred in the common area, her claim was denied because the policy did not cover properties used for student housing.

3. Unapproved Renovations

Explanation: Making renovations to your rental property without notifying your insurer and updating your coverage can lead to claim denial.

When you invest in improving your rental property, it's essential to keep your insurance provider in the loop. Unapproved renovations can create coverage gaps and potential claim denials, leaving you exposed to financial risks.

Prevention: Before embarking on any renovations, whether minor or significant, contact your insurance company to discuss the changes. Provide details about the nature of the renovations, the materials being used, and the estimated completion date. Your insurer can then assess whether the alterations impact your existing coverage or necessitate adjustments.

If your renovations involve structural changes, such as adding an extension, converting spaces, or altering the property's layout, it's crucial to ensure that your policy reflects these modifications. Failing to update your coverage could result in a denied claim if the renovations contribute to the damage or loss.

Example: Sarah, a diligent landlord, decided to upgrade the kitchen in her rental property without notifying her insurer. During the renovation process, a faulty wiring issue caused an electrical fire that spread to other parts of the property, causing significant damage.

When Sarah filed a claim, she was shocked to learn that her insurer denied the claim due to unapproved renovations. The insurer argued that the upgraded electrical system, not covered by her original policy, contributed to the fire. As a result, Sarah faced substantial repair costs out of pocket.

Had Sarah contacted her insurance company before the renovation, she could have adjusted her coverage to include the upgraded electrical system. This simple step would have ensured that her investment was protected, preventing the financial setback she ultimately experienced.

4. Intentional Acts

Explanation: Claims arising from intentional actions, such as vandalism or deliberate damage caused by tenants or other parties, might be denied.

Prevention: To prevent intentional acts from leading to a claim denial, take proactive steps to encourage tenant responsibility and maintain clear lines of communication. Implement robust tenant screening processes to minimize the risk of leasing to individuals with a history of property damage. Additionally, ensure that security measures, such as surveillance cameras or alarm systems, are in place to deter potential vandalism. Educate tenants about their responsibilities for maintaining the property and adhering to the terms outlined in the lease agreement.

Example: A dispute between two tenants escalated, resulting in extensive property damage. The claim for repairs was denied by the insurance company due to the intentional nature of the damage. To avoid similar situations, landlords should prioritize conflict resolution strategies, provide clear guidelines for tenant behavior, and foster a sense of community within the property to discourage intentional acts of harm.

5. Negligence

Explanation: Negligence on the part of the landlord in maintaining the rental property and addressing maintenance issues can lead to claim denial. Insurance companies expect landlords to fulfill their duty of care in ensuring the property is well-maintained and safe for tenants. Failing to meet this responsibility can jeopardize your claim in the event of a covered loss or damage.

Detailed Explanation: Negligence involves the failure to exercise reasonable care or take necessary precautions to prevent harm or damage. In the context of landlord insurance, negligence encompasses a wide range of situations, including inadequate property maintenance, delayed repairs, and disregard for safety concerns.

A claim denial based on negligence may occur if the insurance company determines that your actions or lack thereof contributed to the loss or damage. For instance, if a tenant reports a leaking roof and you fail to address the issue promptly, resulting in interior water damage, the insurance company might view your inaction as negligence and deny the claim.

Ways to Avoid Being Denied:

  1. Regular Inspections: Conduct regular property inspections to identify and address potential maintenance issues early on. Promptly fix leaks, repair structural damage, and address safety concerns.

  2. Timely Repairs: Address tenant-reported maintenance requests promptly. Failure to take timely action can be seen as negligence and lead to a denied claim.

  3. Documentation: Keep detailed records of property maintenance, repairs, and communication with tenants. This documentation can serve as evidence of your proactive approach in case of a claim.

  4. Safety Measures: Ensure the property is equipped with safety features such as smoke detectors, fire extinguishers, and secure entry points. Implementing adequate safety measures demonstrates your commitment to tenant well-being.


John owns a duplex and rents out both units. One of the tenants, Lisa, reported a malfunctioning heater that emitted a strange odor. However, John dismissed the complaint and did not arrange for repairs. A few weeks later, a faulty electrical connection in the heater led to a small fire that caused extensive smoke damage to the property.

When John filed an insurance claim for the smoke damage restoration, the insurer conducted an investigation and discovered that John had neglected to address the reported heater issue. The insurer deemed John's negligence as a contributing factor to the fire damage and subsequently denied the claim.

In this scenario, John's failure to address the maintenance concern in a timely manner and his neglect of tenant safety led to a claim denial based on negligence. To avoid a similar situation, landlords should prioritize tenant safety, promptly address maintenance issues, and keep records of all interactions and repairs.

Negligence is a significant factor that can result in claim denials for landlord insurance. Demonstrating a proactive approach to property maintenance, addressing tenant concerns promptly, and prioritizing safety can help landlords avoid potential claim denial based on negligence. By fulfilling your duty of care as a responsible landlord, you not only ensure the well-being of your tenants but also safeguard your investment property and insurance coverage.

6. Misrepresentation

Explanation: Misrepresentation occurs when inaccurate or incomplete information is provided during the application process or policy updates. If the insurance company discovers that important details have been misrepresented, it may result in a claim denial.

Prevention: To avoid misrepresentation, ensure that all information you provide to the insurance company is accurate and complete. This includes details about the property, its occupancy, safety measures, and any other relevant information. When applying for insurance or making policy updates, take the time to carefully review the information before submission.

Example: Sarah owned a duplex and decided to rent out one of the units. When applying for landlord insurance, she stated that both units were occupied by families. However, she later converted one unit into a short-term vacation rental without informing the insurer. A fire occurred in the vacation rental unit, causing significant damage. When the insurance company investigated, they discovered the misrepresentation regarding the occupancy of the units. As a result, Sarah's claim was denied due to material misrepresentation.

In this case, Sarah could have avoided the claim denial by accurately disclosing the change in occupancy to the insurance company. It's crucial to be transparent and provide truthful information to ensure that your coverage accurately reflects the circumstances of your rental property.

7. Non-Payment of Premiums

Explanation: Failure to pay insurance premiums on time can result in a lapsed policy, leaving you vulnerable to claim denials.

Prevention: Set up automatic payments or create a reminder system to ensure timely premium payments.

Example: Sarah, a diligent landlord, inadvertently missed her premium payment due to a busy schedule. Shortly after, a tenant-caused fire led to substantial damage. Unfortunately, Sarah's claim was denied as her policy had lapsed.

Ensuring Premium Payment:

Life can get busy, and it's easy to overlook premium payment deadlines. To avoid the risk of a lapsed policy:

  • Automatic Payments: Many insurers offer automatic payment options, ensuring premiums are paid on time without requiring your constant attention.

  • Calendar Reminders: Set up reminders on your phone or calendar well in advance of the premium due date to ensure you have enough time to make the payment.

Non-payment of premiums is a common reason for denied claims, but it's one that can easily be prevented with proper planning. Set up automatic payments or reminders to ensure your coverage remains active, protecting your investment and providing you with peace of mind.

8. Failure to Cooperate

Explanation: Lack of cooperation during the claims process can result in claim denial. Insurance companies require accurate information and timely communication to assess and process claims effectively.

Prevention: It's essential to fully cooperate with your insurance provider throughout the claims process. Provide all requested documents, information, and assistance promptly. Respond to inquiries, phone calls, and emails in a timely manner. Maintain open and transparent communication to ensure a smooth claims experience.

Example: Jennifer's rental property suffered extensive water damage due to a burst pipe. When the insurance adjuster requested access to assess the damage, Jennifer repeatedly postponed the appointment and failed to provide the necessary documentation. Her claim was denied due to her lack of cooperation, leaving her responsible for the repair costs. To avoid such situations, always prioritize active and transparent engagement with your insurance provider during the claims process. Remember, your cooperation plays a pivotal role in expediting the resolution of your claim and ensuring your coverage is effective when you need it most.

9. Property Condition

Explanation: The condition of your rental property plays a pivotal role in the approval of insurance claims. Insurance companies expect landlords to maintain their properties in a safe and habitable condition. Claims may be denied if damage or loss is a result of a property's deteriorated condition, lack of upkeep, or failure to adhere to safety standards.

Prevention: Prioritize routine property maintenance and inspections to identify and address potential issues promptly. Keep detailed records of maintenance activities, repairs, and renovations. Regularly review safety measures, such as smoke detectors, fire extinguishers, and security systems, to ensure they are functioning correctly.

Example: Alan owns a rental property with an aging roof that he has neglected to repair. A severe storm causes extensive water damage to the interior. When Alan files an insurance claim for the damages, it is denied due to the deteriorated roof's contribution to the loss. To prevent such a scenario, landlords like Alan should have proactively maintained the property, including the roof, to ensure its structural integrity.

Scenario: Rachel, a diligent landlord, regularly inspects her rental property and addresses maintenance issues promptly. During an inspection, she discovers a small leak under the sink and arranges for immediate repairs. A few weeks later, the same area experiences a major plumbing failure, causing significant water damage to the property. When Rachel files an insurance claim, it is approved because she can demonstrate her efforts to maintain the property's condition and her swift response to the initial issue.

Preventive Measures:

  1. Conduct regular property inspections: Schedule routine inspections to identify and address maintenance needs promptly.

  2. Address repairs promptly: Attend to repairs and maintenance tasks as soon as they are identified to prevent issues from escalating.

  3. Document maintenance activities: Maintain comprehensive records of maintenance, repairs, and renovations performed on the property.

  4. Invest in preventive measures: Implement safety measures, such as fire alarms, carbon monoxide detectors, and security systems, to minimize risks.

  5. Stay informed: Stay updated on local building codes and safety regulations to ensure your property meets required standards.

Maintaining your rental property's condition not only helps prevent insurance claim denials but also enhances tenant satisfaction and protects your long-term investment. Regular upkeep demonstrates your commitment to providing a safe and habitable living environment for your tenants, ultimately contributing to a successful and mutually beneficial landlord-tenant relationship.

10. Wear and Tear

Explanation: Claims based on normal wear and tear or gradual deterioration may be denied, as these are typically excluded from insurance coverage. Wear and tear refers to the natural and expected decline in the condition of a property over time due to regular use and aging.

Prevention: While wear and tear cannot be entirely avoided, there are steps you can take to mitigate its effects and ensure your property remains well-maintained.

  • Conduct Regular Inspections: Regularly inspect your rental property to identify areas that may be experiencing wear and tear. This allows you to address minor issues before they escalate into significant problems.

  • Implement Preventive Maintenance: Create a schedule for routine maintenance tasks, such as painting, replacing worn-out flooring, and servicing appliances. Implementing preventive maintenance can help extend the lifespan of various components and reduce the impact of wear and tear.

  • Choose Durable Materials: When renovating or furnishing your property, opt for high-quality, durable materials that are designed to withstand regular use. This can minimize the effects of wear and tear and reduce the frequency of replacements.

Example: Jane owns a rental property with hardwood floors that have been in place for several years. Over time, the floors have developed scratches and worn areas due to foot traffic. When a tenant requested a claim for the restoration of the floors, Jane's insurance company denied the claim, citing wear and tear as the cause of the damage.

In this case, Jane could have taken preventive measures by placing protective rugs or mats in high-traffic areas or considering periodic refinishing of the hardwood floors. While wear and tear is inevitable, proactive maintenance can help mitigate its impact and ensure that the property remains in good condition.

Understanding the concept of wear and tear is crucial for landlords to set realistic expectations regarding insurance coverage. While wear and tear itself is not covered by insurance, landlords can play an active role in minimizing its effects through regular maintenance, careful material selection, and preventive measures. By addressing wear and tear proactively, landlords can maintain the long-term value of their investment and reduce the likelihood of claim denials related to this common issue.

In Conclusion: Maintaining your rental property's condition and adhering to policy terms are critical factors in avoiding claim denials. By addressing property issues promptly, conducting regular maintenance, and fostering responsible tenant behavior, you can significantly reduce the risk of claim denial and protect your valuable investment. Remember to consult with an experienced insurance professional to tailor your coverage to your specific needs and circumstances, ensuring comprehensive protection for your rental property.


Home &

Auto Insurance 


Much More...
bottom of page